The Executioner Read online

  ‘What do we have?’ Hunter asked in a calm voice.

  ‘We just started. We got here fifteen minutes ago, so at the moment I know just about as much as you do, with one exception.’ Brindle pointed to the body. ‘It looks like that used to be Father Fabian.’

  ‘Looks like?’ Hunter instinctively allowed his eyes to search the area. ‘You haven’t found the head yet?’

  ‘Not yet,’ Brindle answered, casting a questioning look towards the two other crime-lab agents, who shook their heads.

  ‘Who found the body?’

  ‘The altar boy, Hermano something. When he came into the church this morning he was greeted with what you see here.’

  ‘Where’s he?’

  ‘In the back,’ Brindle answered with a head tilt. ‘There’s an officer with him, but not surprisingly he’s in a bit of a shock.’

  ‘Approximate time of death?’

  ‘Rigor mortis is well on its way. I’d say somewhere around eight to twelve hours ago. Definitely sometime last night. Not this morning.’

  Hunter kneeled down and studied the body for a while longer. ‘No defensive wounds?’

  ‘Nope.’ Brindle shook his head. ‘It looks like the victim has no other wounds of any nature. He was killed quickly.’

  Hunter switched his attention to the trail of blood that started at the body and moved up the steps leading to the altar.

  ‘It doesn’t get any better once you get up there,’ Brindle commented as he followed Hunter’s stare. ‘In fact, I’d say it gets more complicated for you guys.’

  Six

  Garcia tore his eyes away from the body and faced the forensic agent. ‘What do you mean?’

  Brindle scratched his nose and faced him. ‘Well, you’re the ones who’ll have to figure out what all this means. The pattern of blood splatters up there—’ he shook his head, considering ‘—it doesn’t seem random.’

  ‘Human blood?’ Hunter asked.

  ‘As opposed to dog’s blood?’ Brindle countered, pointing to the dog’s head.

  ‘Uh-huh.’

  ‘Can’t say for certain yet. Very hard to tell just by looking at it. Their properties are very similar.’

  Hunter climbed up the altar steps in one smooth movement. Garcia and Brindle followed. The place was covered in blood, but Brindle was right – there was definitely a pattern. Some sort of symmetry. On the floor, a thin continuous crimson trail created a circle all around the altar. On the wall directly behind it, there was a long, uneven diagonal splash, as if someone had dipped a paintbrush in the blood and flicked it against the wall. Hundreds of smaller splatters littered the once-crisp white altar cloth.

  ‘Usually when the distribution of blood covers such a large area, it’s due to one of two types of struggle,’ Brindle explained. ‘A fight, where both parties involved run around punching each other and bleeding all over the place, or an injured victim struggling to get away from his attacker.’

  ‘The splatters aren’t consistent with a fight scenario or a runaway struggle,’ Hunter said, analyzing the pattern. ‘The distance between them – the shapes – it’s all too symmetric, almost calculated. This blood trail was intentionally created by the killer, not the victim,’ he added calmly.

  ‘I agree,’ Brindle said, folding his arms over his chest. ‘This wasn’t a fight, and Father Fabian didn’t get a chance to run away from anything.’

  ‘What gets me is, if the priest was killed down there—’ Garcia pointed to the body ‘—how did all this blood get up here?’

  Brindle shrugged.

  Hunter approached the altar and carefully walked around it, studying the thin blood trail on the floor. He stopped when he’d completed a full circle.

  ‘How tall are you, Mike?’

  ‘Six-four, why?’

  ‘How about you, Carlos?’

  ‘Six-two.’

  ‘Come here.’ Hunter motioned Garcia closer. ‘Walk with me slowly,’ he said as his partner joined him. ‘Stay about a foot away from the trail. Take one step at a time and walk naturally. Start from right here.’ He indicated a point on the floor directly behind the center of the altar.

  The two other crime-lab agents stopped what they were doing and joined Mike Brindle by one of the powerlights.

  Garcia had taken only four steps when Hunter asked him to stop. Bending over, he quickly checked Garcia’s foot position in relation to the trail before allowing him to continue. Four steps later, Hunter stopped Garcia once again. Four steps after that, the circle was completed.

  ‘Twelve steps in total,’ Garcia said with an intrigued look.

  Hunter called Brindle over and asked him to do exactly the same as Garcia had just done.

  ‘Eleven steps from me,’ Brindle said when he reached his starting point after a full circle.

  ‘I’d say the killer’s Garcia’s height,’ Hunter concluded. ‘Six-two, give or take half an inch.’

  Seven

  Brindle’s inquisitive stare stayed on the blood trail for a moment before moving to Hunter. ‘And how did you come to that?’ he asked.

  ‘Because of these breakaway splatters over here.’ Hunter pointed to two separate points on the floor around the altar where several drops of blood created a foot-long, outbound, breakaway line from the circular trail.

  Brindle was joined by the two other crime-lab agents.

  ‘I don’t follow,’ one of them said.

  ‘If you had to draw a circle of blood around this altar, but you had no paintbrush, what’d you do?’ Hunter asked.

  ‘With this much blood,’ the crime-lab agent offered, looking at the pool that surrounded the body, ‘you could fill a cup with it and pour it onto the floor.’

  ‘Too messy,’ Hunter disagreed. ‘You wouldn’t be able to control the pouring, unless you had a container with a beak.’

  ‘It’s a drip trail, anyway,’ Brindle said confidently. ‘Blood wasn’t poured onto the floor. It dripped onto it.’

  ‘That’s also my understanding.’ Hunter nodded.

  ‘OK. Still, how does that give you the UNSUB’s height?’ The crime-lab agent pressed.

  ‘Imagine someone walking around the altar holding a small object saturated with blood,’ Hunter explained, moving to the front of the altar. ‘The excess dripping onto the floor.’

  ‘A small object like a candle?’ the shorter of the two agents asked, lifting a half-melted altar candle by its wick. Its bottom half was stained red as if it’d been dipped in a shallow glass of blood. ‘I found it to the left of the altar.’ He brought it closer, allowing both detectives and Brindle to have a look at it.

  ‘This is it,’ Hunter agreed.

  ‘Bag it,’ Brindle commanded.

  ‘So the killer dips the end of the candle into some blood and uses it to create the circular trail,’ the agent said, dropping the candle into a cellophane bag. ‘What about the breakaway splatters?’

  ‘A candle isn’t absorbent enough,’ Hunter explained. ‘It can hold only a very limited amount of blood before it stops dripping.’

  ‘So the killer had to re-dip it,’ Garcia confirmed.

  ‘Exactly.’

  Brindle thought about it for a few seconds. ‘So you figured the killer managed only four steps before having to re-dip the candle in blood.’

  Hunter nodded. ‘I’d say he was holding the blood container close to his body. The breakaway lines are the drips from the blood container back to the trail.’

  ‘And they come at exactly four of Garcia’s steps apart,’ Brindle concluded.

  Another nod from Hunter. ‘Your steps overshot it and mine fell short of the mark. I’m six foot tall.’

  ‘But why create the circle around the altar?’ Garcia asked. ‘Some sort of ritual?’

  There was no answer. Everyone went quiet for a while.

  ‘As I’ve said—’ Brindle broke the silence ‘—you’re the ones who’ll have to figure out what all this means. The blood splatters, the dog’s head shoved down the p
riest’s neck . . . It looks like the killer is trying to get a message out.’

  ‘Yeah, and the message is I’m a fucking psycho,’ Garcia murmured, looking back down at the body.

  ‘Have you ever seen anything like this before, Mike?’ Hunter asked, tilting his head towards the body. ‘I mean, a dog’s head shoved down someone’s neck?’

  Brindle shook his head. ‘I’ve seen a lot of bad and weird stuff, but this is a first for me.’

  ‘It’s gotta mean something,’ Garcia said. ‘No way the killer did it just for the heck of it.’

  ‘I’m guessing if you haven’t found the head, you haven’t found a weapon either,’ Hunter said, now studying the blood splatters on the wall.

  ‘Not so far.’

  ‘Any guess what it could be?’

  ‘Hopefully, the autopsy will be able to answer that question, but I can tell you the cut looks smooth. No edges. No signs of hacking. Definitely a very sharp instrument. One that could’ve performed the cut in one clean sweep.’

  ‘An axe?’ Garcia enquired.

  ‘If the killer is skillful and strong enough, sure.’

  Hunter frowned as he studied the altar again. Other than the bloodstained cloth, there was only one object left on it. A gold-plated chalice adorned by silver crucifixes. It was lying on its side, as if someone had knocked it over. Its shiny surface was sprinkled with blood. Hunter bent down and twisted his body so he could have a look inside its bowl without touching it.

  ‘There’s blood inside this chalice,’ he said as his eyes carried on analyzing the holy cup.

  ‘Does that surprise you?’ Brindle asked with a chuckle. ‘Look around. There’s blood everywhere, Robert. It’s like a blood bomb exploded in here.’

  ‘I’d say that’s what the killer used as a blood container to dip the candle in,’ Garcia emphasized.

  ‘I agree, but . . .’ Hunter made a come here gesture with his left hand. Garcia and Brindle joined him, both bending down to draw eye level with the chalice. Hunter pointed to a faint print on its border edge.

  ‘I’ll be damned. It looks like a mouth print,’ Brindle said, surprised.

  ‘Wait a sec,’ Garcia shot back wide-eyed. ‘You think the killer drank the priest’s blood?’

  Eight

  The room was small, badly lit and devoid of any luxury. The walls were papered in a dull blue and white pattern with several framed religious drawings hanging from them. Against the east wall stood a tall mahogany bookcase lined with old-fashioned hardcovers. To the right of the entrance door, the room extended out into a small kitchen. A terrified-looking boy was sitting on an iron-framed single bed that occupied the space between the kitchen and the back wall. He was small and skinny; around five foot six, with a narrow chin, tiny brown eyes set closely together and a pinched nose.

  ‘We’ll take it from here. Thank you,’ Hunter said to the officer standing next to the bookcase as he and Garcia entered the room. The boy didn’t seem to notice them. His stare was cemented on the untouched cup of coffee in his hands. His eyes were bloodshot and puffy from crying.

  Hunter noticed a kettle sitting on a two-burner hotplate.

  ‘Can I get you another cup of coffee? That one looks to have gone cold,’ he asked, once the officer had left.

  The boy finally looked up with terrified eyes. ‘No, sir, thank you.’ His voice a whisper.

  ‘Do you mind if I sit down?’ Hunter asked, moving a step closer.

  A shy shake of the head.

  He took a seat on the bed next to the boy. Garcia chose to stand.

  ‘My name’s Robert Hunter. I’m a detective with the Homicide Division. That tall and ugly guy over there is my partner, Detective Carlos Garcia.’

  A hint of a smile graced the boy’s lips as his eyes stole a peek at Garcia. He introduced himself as Hermano Cordobes.

  ‘Would you rather we spoke in Spanish, muchacho?’ Hunter asked, leaning forward to mimic Hermano’s position. Both elbows resting on the knees.

  ‘No, sir. English is fine.’

  Hunter breathed, relieved. ‘I’m glad, ’cos muchacho is pretty much the only word I know in Spanish.’

  This time the ice-breaker worked and they got a full smile from the boy.

  For the first few minutes they talked about how Hermano came to be the altar boy at the Seven Saints church. Father Fabian had found him begging on the streets when he was eleven. He’d just turned fourteen two weeks ago. He explained he’d run away from home and from a violent father when he was ten.

  Daylight had started to crawl into the room through the old curtains covering the window just behind Hermano’s bed when Hunter decided the boy was relaxed enough. It was time to get serious.

  Nine

  ‘Can you run me through what happened this morning?’ Hunter asked in a calm voice.

  Hermano looked at him and his bottom lip quivered. ‘I got up at a quarter past four, showered, said my prayers and made my way to the church at a quarter to five. I always get here early. I have to make sure everything’s set up properly for the first Mass at six-thirty.’

  Hunter smiled kindly, allowing him to continue in his own time.

  ‘As soon as I entered the church I knew something wasn’t right.’

  ‘How come?’

  Hermano brought his right hand to his mouth and chewed on what was left of a nail. ‘A few of the candles were still burning. Father Fabian always made sure they were all put out after closing the church.’

  ‘Did Father Fabian always close the church by himself?’

  ‘Yes.’ He started chewing on another nail. ‘It was the only time of day he had the church all to himself. He liked that.’ Hermano’s voice trailed off as tears started to roll down his cheeks.

  Hunter fetched a paper tissue from his jacket pocket.

  ‘Thank you, sir. I’m sorry . . .’

  ‘There’s no need to be sorry,’ Hunter said understandingly. ‘Take your time. I know how difficult this is.’

  Hermano wiped the tears from his face and drew another deep breath. ‘I could tell that the altar was a mess. The candle-holders were on the floor. The chalice was tipped over on its side, and the altar cloth looked dirty. Smeared with something.’

  ‘Did you notice if there was anyone else in the church?’

  ‘No, sir. I don’t believe there was. The place was as quiet as it’s always been at that time. The front door was locked.’

  ‘OK, what did you do after that?’ Hunter asked, his eyes taking in every reaction from Hermano.

  ‘I walked up to the altar to check what was going on. I thought that maybe someone had broken into the church and sprayed paint everywhere. Like graffiti, you know? This isn’t the best of neighborhoods. Some of the gangs around here don’t have no respect for nothing. Not even Our Lord Jesus Christ.’

  ‘Have you had problems with gangs in here before?’ Hunter asked while Garcia checked the kitchen.

  ‘That’s the funny thing, sir. We never had any trouble. Everyone loved Father Fabian.’

  ‘How about break-ins? Either into the church or into these sleeping quarters?’

  ‘No, sir. Never. We don’t really have anything of value.’

  Hunter nodded. ‘So what happened next?’

  ‘I didn’t know what to do. I knew there was no way I’d be able to get the church cleaned and ready for the six-thirty Mass. When I got to the other side of the altar I saw it, on the floor next to the confessional. I panicked. I thought it was the devil.’

  ‘The devil?’ Hunter arched his eyebrows.

  Hermano was crying again. ‘The man with a dog’s head all covered in blood. It looked like the devil. But it was Father Fabian.’

  ‘How could you tell?’ Garcia asked.

  ‘The ring.’

  ‘What ring?’

  ‘Big gold ring with the image of Saint George slaying a dragon on the left hand,’ Hunter said, lifting his hand and dangling his ring finger.

  Garcia bit his bottom lip
, half annoyed he’d failed to notice the ring back in the church.

  ‘That’s right, sir,’ Hermano said, impressed. ‘Father Fabian never took it off. A present from his grandmother, he told me. When I saw the ring I knew it was him. It was Father Fabian.’ Hermano broke down, burying his head in his hands. His sobs were violent enough to jerk his body every few seconds.

  Ten

  Grief and silence are perfect partners. Hunter understood this very well. He’d been around people suffering from the shock of discovering a dead body too many times. Words, no matter how comforting, rarely made a difference. He offered the young altar boy a new paper tissue and waited as he dried his tears. When he turned to face Hunter, his eyes were cherry red.

  ‘I don’t understand, sir. Who’d do something like that to Father Fabian? He never hurt a soul. He was always willing to help. No matter who. No matter what time. If anyone needed him, he’d be there.’

  Hunter kept his voice calm and steady. ‘Hermano, you look like an intelligent boy and I’m not gonna lie to you. We don’t have the answers right now, but I promise we’ll do our best to find them. If it’s OK with you, we still need to ask you a few more questions.’

  Hermano blew his nose into the paper tissue and nodded nervously.

  Hunter retrieved a pen and a small black notebook from his jacket pocket. ‘When did you last see Father Fabian?’

  ‘Last night, sir, just before confessions started.’

  ‘And what time did it start?’

  ‘At a quarter to nine.’

  ‘That late?’ Garcia cut in.

  ‘Usually confessions go from four to five in the afternoons,’ Hermano explained. ‘But on the weeks leading up to Christmas it gets a lot busier. The afternoon sessions aren’t enough to deal with the number of people who come in. Father Fabian runs a second session around an hour before closing time.’